BLOG
Photo by Emily Scott
14 Complicated Situations I Can Guide You Through (as your Financial Sherpa)
We often think of finances as a calculative and dry subject. We believe that the cold numbers will lead us to an objectively correct way to spend our money. However, life is full of unexpected and difficult choices and sometimes there isn’t a purely data-driven answer available.
In these times you need to examine factors like your mental state, your money story, future goals, and personal relationships to figure out what is right for you. I’ve covered 14 situations of times that disrupt our emotions and make it the most challenging to make a smart decision.
We often think of finances as a calculative and dry subject. We believe that the cold numbers will lead us to an objectively correct way to spend our money. However, life is full of unexpected and difficult choices and sometimes there isn’t a purely data-driven answer available.
In these times you need to examine factors like your mental state, your money story, future goals, and personal relationships to figure out what is right for you. I’ve covered 14 situations of times that disrupt our emotions and make it the most challenging to make a smart decision.
Table of Contents:
- Managing Finances After the Death of a Spouse
- Dealing with Financial Imbalances Between Partners
- Getting Your Bearings after a Divorce
- Unexpected Financial Windfalls
- Windfall Falling Through
- Economic Shifts Outside Personal Control
- The Money Side of Having Children
- Caring for Elderly Family Members
- Being Responsible for Extended Family
- What to Leave my Kids
- Engaging in Meaningful and Personal Philanthropy
- Harnessing Our Inner Bag Lady
- How to Understand My Money Story
- Healthily Reflecting on Our Financial Habits
Managing Finances After the Death of a Spouse
The death of a loved one starts you on an emotional rollercoaster. Everything happens abruptly and your surroundings can blur together. There are no places to get off and you’re forced to ride it out until the end.
For most people in this situation, collecting and organizing financial information is far from the front of their mind. However, certain financial decisions can’t be put on the back burner for long. Important payments like your mortgage require action even in times of grief.
So, if you’re feeling overwhelmed, then it might be a good idea to bring in a professional to help you prioritize. They’ll take care of everything that needs immediate attention so that you can have the time you need to grieve.
This process allows you to approach your finances from a healthy, stable perspective. After all, grief can convince us to make rash and improper decisions.
In the meantime, take the time to get your emotions in order and seek out help if you need it. Visit support groups and speak to people in similar circumstances. Get as close to normalcy as possible with your children, friends, and family. When you’ve settled down, then you’ll be able to make financial decisions that take care of your future and honor your partner’s wishes.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Dealing with Financial Imbalances Between Partners
There are many reasons why one partner may earn less than the other. Perhaps one of you left your job to take care of the house and children. Maybe one of your chosen professions is more lucrative. Regardless of the reason, power imbalances can take a toll on even the most loving and supportive relationships.
When one person is less financially stable as an individual, it can feel like they have a smaller voice in related decisions. Feelings of inadequacy or loss of personal power will inevitably lead to an increasing number of arguments.
This could also appear in the form of guilt from both sides. While the lower-earning partner can feel like they’re not contributing enough to the relationship. That they’re being one-sidedly cared for. On the other hand, the higher-earner can pick up on these feelings and develop guilt over harming their loved ones. Inadvertently or not.
Combating this requires understanding what each person values in the relationship. Maybe their Money Story led them to place a lower value on financial contributions. Maybe they grew up truly believing that all money is shared in a partnership. Through understanding each other’s money stories, you can truly understand what you bring (or don’t bring) to your partner’s life.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Getting Your Bearings after a Divorce
Divorce is an emotional death. It’s the symbolic representation of taking your relationship and burying it 10 feet deep. However, unlike the ancient Egyptians, our assets and wealth aren’t buried with the body.
Emotions of fear and anxiety can crop up when you go through a divorce. There’s the obvious fear of ceding your involvement in your children’s lives to your ex-partner. But there are also fears of losing your lifestyle and your future security.
Getting over this fear is necessary to have a fair and clean divorce. If you don’t, then you’ll be approaching conversations under a combative cloud. The importance of an asset to each partner isn’t necessarily 1:1 with its financial value.
Understanding your ex-partner’s money story will greatly help in divvying everything up so that you each get an equal share of what’s important to you.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Unexpected Financial Windfalls
So, you’ve had a stroke of good fortune and money has unexpectedly fallen into your life. You probably have a laundry list of things you’ve always wanted if only you had the money to buy them. But there’s a difference between a list of things you dream about and what you need.
Scrap that list. It’s time to make a new one.
Keep in mind that a financial windfall has innate value even if you don’t spend it on anything at all. However, if you’re adamant about a “use it or lose it” mindset, then try to incorporate your values into the purchasing decisions. Learn what types of things bring you the most emotional satisfaction or freedom.
By understanding what’s most important to you, you’re able to better align your spending with your value system. Rather than seek instant gratification, it’s better to use it on long-term investments that fulfill yourself in a myriad of ways.
For example, do you feel weighed down by credit card or student debt? Wouldn’t it be liberating to finally be rid of it (or at least a chunk of it?)
Do you value time spent with your family? Then buy something that you all can do together and build memories with. Learn to direct your purchases in this manner, and you’ll gain much more satisfaction from your good fortune.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Windfall Falling Through
We structure our lives around certain certainties or what we believe are certainties. Things like being paid on time this week. Getting at least ‘X’ amount of money in our Christmas bonus. You may even be counting on receiving money left in someone’s will.
We sometimes forget that nothing is ever certain. Bonuses can be canceled, paychecks can be late, and wills can be revised without anyone knowing. Even if you’re holding onto an investment or an asset, until you’ve taken steps to cash out on it, then it’s not 100 percent reliable. Stocks can plummet and property can drop in value. Nothing is certain. Maintain the mindset that money you can’t hold in your own two hands isn’t yours.
However, if you’ve already made the mistake of spending money you don’t have, then you need to get on damage control. Get the money back if possible or find ways to cut down your spending until you make up the difference. The slower you move, the bigger the problem becomes.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Economic Shifts Outside Personal Control
It sucks to say, but life isn’t fair. Our finances will be pressured at times regardless of how responsible and fiscal we are. Global events like pandemics, wars, and political schemes can ruin economies and wrench our jobs away from us.
This unfairness unleashes anger and pity for ourselves. An understandable response for when the world gives us the bird. But just as there was nothing you could do to stop it from happening, there’s also nothing you can do to change it.
So, we should learn how to ride the waves as gracefully as we can. Figure out where you can cut costs in your daily life and look for temporary (possibly lower-paying) jobs to tide you over. Do whatever you can to get yourself stable enough to stand tall once more.
Above all, never convince yourself that, “Things can’t get any worse.” There’s no guarantee that whatever caused your problem won’t continue. Because it can. But adapting quickly is the key to minimizing damages and preserving the key parts of your lifestyle.
~~~~~~~~~~~
The Money Side of Having Children
One of the biggest choices we ever have to make in life is the decision to bring children into it. It’s not a simple shower idea that you’re rolling with on a whim. There are hundreds of things to consider, like your maturity, available time, and financial state.
It requires you to partially look into the future. To predict what your life will look like, and how it will transform after you have a child.
Even if you think you’re well off, the costs of a child can be painfully surprising. Things like insurance, medical bills, specialized food, toys, and sleeping equipment will strain your budget. Not to mention the diapers. More diapers than you can imagine.
You need to consider what you and your partner are willing to give up and what you’re not. Things like personal training and fancy restaurants may need to be put aside for a while if you want to give your child the life you imagined. What’s removable from your life while still allowing enough resources to fulfill yourself? After you know that, ask yourself, “will giving those up let me save enough money to raise a child?”
This doesn’t only apply when your children are chubby and cute. It extends to the moodier phases as well. There are two life events that many parents dread having to pay for.
College and marriage.
Both are ridiculously expensive events in your child’s life. You need to decide early on a reasonable target you want to hit and how much you want to help your child. Like with all goals, setting a target greatly increases your odds of reaching it.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Caring for Elderly Family Members
As we get older and gain more life experience, we get a better perspective of what our parents went through to raise us. So, when it’s our turn to take care of them, it’s hard to say no, even if it’s not what we imagined for ourselves.
If you assume the role of a primary caregiver, then you’re over 10 percent more likely to report financial difficulty than secondary caregivers. After all, you’re taking on an adult who likely has a variety of medical needs.
Look for the early signs. If you know that illness runs in your family or your parents may struggle in their later years, then you’ll want to start preparing early. If possible, put aside some money to cover their future living and medical expenses.
Do your research and be honest with yourself about how much their care will cost you. It might not be enough to save whatever just happens to be left over. You might have to give up certain luxuries if you want to save enough for their future.
To get a good estimate of your parent’s future expenses, discuss what THEY expect from their future. You might not be able to provide everything, but it’s a good starting point to find some common ground. There’s likely to be a large number of concessions, but remember that it should be a 2-way street. It’s vital that you both find ways to stay happy without trampling on the other’s lifestyle.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Being Responsible for Extended Family Members
One of the less desirable consequences of success is the barrage of expectations you get from those around you. They expect you to help them out because “you can afford it” and they turn you into the villain for not doing enough to share your success.
This can be particularly frustrating when these expectations are coming from your spouse’s side of things. The over-reliant family is a classic hook seen in dozens of family comedies. Common cast members include the hateful mother-in-law, the overbearing father-in-law, and the deadbeat brother.
It’s hard to find the line between helping out family and being taken advantage of. But you must strike the right balance if you want your spouse to maintain close ties with her blood. Many couples try to reach an agreement with the extended family, but that isn’t the correct approach.
In the end, you’re doing this for your spouse. So, they need to have the biggest voice in what’s acceptable. It’s their money story and emotions that will decide if you’re helping too much or too little. Before you hand over a cent, make sure that you create guidelines for the generosity that you’re both happy with.
~~~~~~~~~~~
What to Leave my Kids
Raise your hand if you enjoy speaking to spoiled and entitled children. Anyone? I didn’t think so.
Everyone wants to raise their kids to be upstanding and successful people. Leaving them too much money after you pass might give them the agency to learn lessons that go against that goal. Alternatively, leaving them nothing may hurt their feelings.
You want to leave them enough so that they can feel secure and that they know you cared for them. Finding this sweet spot is like performing advanced calculus without a trusty “TI” calculator.
It starts with dissecting what each child wants to achieve in their life. What kind of lifestyle do they want to lead and what dreams do they want to pursue. Their money story, both past and present. Considering all of this show them, on an emotional level, that you understand them and want what’s best for them.
As their parent, you play an ENORMOUS role in developing their money stories Become a model of the financial credo that you want your children to adopt and let them know what’s important to you. Do you value taking financial risks or playing it safe? Is frugality important to you? Teaching your children these things about you tells them what to expect when you pass.
So, as long as you practice what you preach, then your children are more likely to be understanding and respectful of what you leave them.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Engaging in Meaningful and Personal Philanthropy
There are literally thousands of charitable efforts out there. Choosing which ones to dedicate your time, emotion, and money toward is going to come down to your money story. People tend to engage more deeply in philanthropy when they’re both knowledgeable and connected to the cause.
So, it stands to reason that you’ll be most helpful to organizations that meet those requirements. You’ll need to understand how different organizations operate to achieve this. Find ways to engage with them and come to each conversation curious.
Ask their representatives and volunteers questions to see if they align with your desire for change. This includes queries about their current and future plans. If the cause doesn’t ignite your passion then keep searching for one that does. This will enable you to throw yourself into it more completely.
Understand that meaningful philanthropy isn’t about how big of a check you can write. If you’re not engaging on an emotional level, then whatever you do will feel empty and unfulfilling.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Harnessing Our Inner Bag Lady
Bag lady syndrome refers to a woman’s fear that, at any point, she’ll be thrown to the streets and have to carry her possessions in a shopping bag. These uncertainties manifest in men as well, however, the trend is more prevalent in women given our lower pay and the pressure on us to leave the workforce.
There are times when this concern comes over me and takes a place in my decision-making. This isn’t all bad. While you shouldn’t let your bag lady syndrome take full control; there are benefits to listening to it every once in a while.
Rather than giving in to the fear, channel it to develop responsible habits in managing and reviewing budgets. Use your concern to motivate you into taking a more active role in your investments and build up reliable safety nets. It can even add a sense of fulfillment when you take it into account.
After all, your bag lady syndrome is part of your money story too. And like with all parts of that story, you gain positive feedback by aligning your financial habits with it. Every time you come under budget will feel that much better.
~~~~~~~~~~~
How to Understand My Money Story
Our money story is defined by all the lessons we’ve learned in our life. Financial or otherwise. It’s the reason that some of us are frugal while others derive joy from frequent spending.
Money stories are a form of emotional expression and understanding them is crucial to making fulfilling money decisions. I work with clients to uncover their money stories and learn how to set goals with their value systems in mind.
Through my workshops and seminars, we hone in on the explicit and implicit messages you’ve been exposed to. Obvious examples include whether you grew up in luxury or watched a family member ruin their life through irresponsible spending. We take these messages and figure out how they have shaped your current habits. This helps you create plans that remove negative feelings about your money and start to use it in a uniquely meaningful manner.
My own money story stems from the tumultuous marriage between my refugee father and depression-era mother. After which my mother was forced to drastically alter her lifestyle. It made me develop a hyper-awareness of any risks a venture might have.
Taking an objective viewpoint is vital in uncovering your money story. We all know how easy it is to lie to ourselves about our past. Discussing your background with a professional or [the right] friend will help you immensely.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Healthily Reflecting on Our Financial Habits
It’s always a good time to look back and evaluate how you’re using your money. It gives you more relevant insight for determining what goals to set moving forward and if your recent choices reflect your money story.
I’ve worked with clients who beat themselves up over failing to stick to their budgets. They restrict themselves in January about how much they’re allowed to spend in December. That’s a little crazy if you think about it. Our circumstances and values can shift dramatically in brief periods of time.
Think about why you went over budget. Did you travel to spend more time with close family or friends? Were you investing more into hobbies that bring you long-term joy? Was there a charity or local project that you contributed to? If your choice of exceeding your budget brings you comparable fulfillment, then maybe it’s your budget that needs to be reevaluated.
Reconstruct your budget with your money story as the central theme. Think about your value hierarchy and make reasonable trade-offs to better match it. This process by itself can help reconcile the nervousness you feel about going over budget since it justifies how you’re directing your funds. Within reason.
If you need help navigating your thoughts and emotions around an important financial decision, you can contact me here or check out some of my online resources.
Preparing Your Relationship for Healthy Financial Discussions
Money is a hard thing to talk about. It fits right in between being honest with your doctor and discussing a “newly renovated” nursing home with your mother-in-law. In fact, we’re taught from an early age to avoid talking about money. Even straightforward subjects like salary and savings are hindered by a layer of taboo. So, imagine the herculean difficulty of trying to talk about any emotional aspects of the subject.
Money is a hard thing to talk about. It fits right in between being honest with your doctor and discussing a “newly renovated” nursing home with your mother-in-law.
In fact, we’re taught from an early age to avoid talking about money. Even straightforward subjects like salary and savings are hindered by a layer of taboo. So, imagine the herculean difficulty of trying to talk about any emotional aspects of the subject.
You’d think that communication gets easier the closer we are with someone, but we all know that isn’t always the case. Disagreements and differences in ideology can spell the end of a relationship if they’re put through enough stress. Most couples don’t want to invite that themselves and choose to steer clear of hot button subjects.
Avoidance only works for so long. Some unforeseen problem will shake your life from its axis and force you to talk about more than just current events. Due to the ubiquity of finance, at least part of that conversation will almost certainly be about money.
And it will test your relationship.
Now, it’s easy to believe the couples that fail this test just weren’t strong enough. That they hadn’t cultivated the openness and honesty of their counterparts.
Rather than a lack of honesty, I’ve observed that many individuals lack the necessary insight into their money story to explain themselves properly. A “money story” is the culmination of all the implicit and explicit financial lessons you’ve learned throughout your life. Our money stories are individually unique. As a result, we’re approaching the conversation from different perspectives which is a big factor in the difficulty in communicating about finances.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Why We Struggle to Communicate
Knowing your financial habits and having insight into them are separate matters. Many people have no trouble explaining their general money philosophy. They describe themselves with simple terms like saver, spender, or investor among other things.
However, such broad definitions don’t cut it in a serious financial discussion, whether it’s with a personal or professional connection. Certainly, the spender will be looser with money while the saver will tighten their grip. They’ll continue to clash as each one struggles to understand why their partner won’t accept their point of view.
This will go on until the relationship breaks or someone thinks to ask, “why do you feel that way?”
Why do you value a safety net so much?
Why do you want to spend money on something like this?
Why are you so keen on following the stock market?
Questions like these probe into a financial habit's emotional or historical reasoning. Instead of playing an argumentative numbers game of “cost v. benefit,” a couple with insight into the reasons behind their habits will form a deeper understanding.
This understanding helps them realize why it’s important that their partner act on their ideology to a certain degree. It’s not just about blindly spending, saving, and investing. Instead, the act of using money in a particular way provides feelings of acknowledgment, safety, validation, or other positive emotional responses. Values that both partners want for the other.
While the questions to ask are relatively straightforward, their answers will be more complicated to sort out. After all, our behaviors are like an emotional puzzle box built by a lifetime of expectations and experiences.
There are thousands upon thousands of pieces that cling together and shape our overall ideology. Little factors like opening a lemonade stand as a kid or your father’s rule of squirreling away 20 percent of every paycheck play a role. Locating the most impactful factors among them takes time and precision.
This becomes even more complex when we introduce an intimate partner into the mix. Having to integrate their feelings and viewpoints is akin to throwing in a handful of new pieces that we can’t find a place for in our puzzle.
It’s only when we share our money stories and present how we think and feel that we can create space for our partners. We rarely discuss this need in our day-to-day, so when it’s time to get serious, it’s hard to land on common ground.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Excavating the Money Story and Finding Common Ground
A few years ago, a couple came to me and detailed a situation that I can only describe as an intermittent war. The prize? Control over a hefty inheritance.
It was one of the classic scenarios between a spender and saver.
The wife earmarked the inheritance as a safety measure. Something to provide for their family if an emergency arose. A “break glass in case of hard times” fund. Her husband considered it an extension of their savings. Something to be used in the present to improve their lives.
Every purchase or expense eclipsing a standard grocery run would spark a contentious debate. Previously agreeable decisions like vacation destinations and home improvements became the backdrop for arguments that slowly eroded their marriage.
Despite the ever-growing conflicts, they continued to treasure each other and wanted the marriage to survive. They felt that it wouldn’t if this game of inheritance tug-of-war wasn’t somehow put to rest.
After hearing both sides’ opening statements, it became clear that the problem had only been approached from a fact-based vantage point. They repeated rationales like saving up for their children or the logistics of adding a third bathroom but didn’t understand why they valued their plans over their partner’s.
They had both grown up in less than favorable circumstances that dramatically influenced their perspectives. Just in different ways. They’d learned harsh lessons and, the harsher the lesson, the more its teachings are adhered to. This is the emotional side of money that often drives our decision-making actions and behaviors.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Her Anxiety
A depression-era home struggling to survive. She learned early on about the pain of living without a safety net. Doing everything to succeed but still surrounded by a family endlessly worried about the next morning.
Two siblings turned to substance abuse and she had the role of the “good and responsible child” hoisted upon her.. Her lesson was to always have a backup so her family could live with a light heart even when times got hard.
~~~~~~~~~~~
His Reward
A father that was incapable of holding down a job. He learned how inconsistent providers hurt everyone around them. Rather than rely on employers, he founded his own company and created a high level of security for himself.
Everything he earned went toward his family because they needed it all. And he was happy to give it to them.
However, when a large sum of unexpected money came in, he wanted to reward himself for his work. He had succeeded where his father had failed and wanted to feel the benefits of that. This was the motivation behind his hyperfocus on using the inheritance money.
While his money always went to supporting his family, this extra money could be used as a reward and make him feel like his efforts had paid off.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Give Some Ground for the Benefit of Both
Understanding your partner’s emotional reasoning is a way to initiate the discussion with common ground to jump off. In the end, you both want the other to feel satisfied and happy about how you’re using the joint money. However, chasing after emotional payoffs isn’t an excuse to be reckless with your finances.
The point is to pin down a way to fulfill both of your needs rather than prioritizing whoever has the more compelling backstory. We’re not in the business of emotionally blackmailing our partners. If only one of you compromises their needs at every turn, then discord will form and cause future conversations to become even harder.
In the inheritance case, the goal was to find a way to let the husband feel rewarded for his success while maintaining the sense of security it brought to the wife. You’ll notice that this is a completely different puzzle than arguing about who’s financial ideology should be applied wholesale to the inheritance.
One of the measures I suggested was creating a stipend. This was a pre-agreed amount of money that the husband had complete autonomy over. So, rather than feeling like nothing he earned went to himself, he could reward himself with an amount that didn’t threaten his wife’s comfort.
Of course, other conflicts arose from their unique experiences, but this was just one way that a little insight completely changed their conversation.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Keys to Having a Balanced and Safe Financial Discussion
While grasping your partner’s ideology is a huge help, it’s still possible for serious discussions to become unnecessarily heated. Setting up a few guidelines ahead of time can mitigate problems and keep the conversation flowing in productive ways.
Remember it’s a Conversation Not a Confrontation: Just as you’re not trying to antagonize your partner, they’re not trying to hurt you either. Keep the dialogue friendly and, if needed, gently address statements that make you feel attacked.
Appreciate Your Partner’s Values: You’re not in a relationship with a carbon copy of yourself. Each person brings unique values and perspectives to the table and it’s the collective’s responsibility to at least hear them out. Keeping an open mind can often keep disputes from turning into full-blown arguments.
Relationship “Shorthand” is Dangerous: It’s easy to assume you know everything about your partner, particularly in lengthy marriages. This leads us to continue discussions under certain assumptions which is a dangerous practice. If you take the time to confirm your partner’s thoughts, it could keep you from creating pointless static. One of my favorite expressions is to “come to the conversation curious.”
Take Time to Reaffirm the Relationship: Things can get passionate (and personal), but take a breath. Remind your partner, or be open to reminders, that the purpose of the discussion is to help you both. Come from a loving place and be obvious about it.
If a financial issue is disrupting your relationship and you want to communicate more effectively with your partner, then you can contact me here or reference our online resources.
Your Legacy, A Guide For Singles
Your legacy is a statement of who you are, how you want to be described, your perspective, values, and principles, AND your consideration of others after you are gone. When you don't have obvious heirs, you get to ideate about how your relationship with money can apply to the various people and organizations that have played a role in your life events and transitions. You have the opportunity to envision the manifestation of your goals and dreams and of those important to you, and how you can contribute to making those visions come true.
THE ASSUMPTIONS WE MAKE
During the transition of married life to divorced life, I was in a doctor's office, filling out the typical paperwork. The question of 'in case of emergency who should we call?' stumped me as I thought, "Now what? Who should they call?" It's strange how a usually straightforward question transforms into more profound thoughts about who and what is important to you. In full disclosure, following this, I learned that my biological father is not the father with whom I grew up, so add the thought of, "for 60 years I have been lying on my medical forms." Who knew a simple piece of paper could generate the reality of the assumptions we make in our lives?
Fast forward to last year and a conversation I was having with a long-term care consultant. I realized that I needed to learn my insurance options now – before I got even older and body parts would start failing even more than they already do! Had I appropriately financially planned for my circumstances?
One of his very first comments was, "Since you are single with no children, you can spend all your money on taking care of yourself."
WHOA. Altogether not my money mindset nor my financial plan, in fact, the opposite of what I want my legacy to be. People make assumptions when there are no apparent heirs, one of which is presuming that you will want to consume your wealth during your lifetime.
~~~~~~~~~~~
YOUR LEGACY IS YOUR MISSION STATEMENT
Your legacy is a statement of who you are, how you want to be described, your perspective, values, and principles, AND your consideration of others after you are gone. When you don't have obvious heirs, you get to ideate about how your relationship with money can apply to the various people and organizations that have played a role in your life events and transitions. You have the opportunity to envision the manifestation of your goals and dreams and of those important to you, and how you can contribute to making those visions come true.
My estate plan is chock full of people and nonprofits I care deeply about, and I want my gratitude to include a financial component. The idea that I wouldn't be able to do that is the antithesis of what money means to me and my mission.
I have a personal mission statement, and I always encourage my clients to have one as well. I call it my NorthStar and the foundational core of my financial decision-making process.
Mine is "I want my money to represent who I want to be as a human being, with my knowledge and emotions aligned to maintain my security, flexibility, freedom, and generosity."
GIVE A GIFT OR CHANGE SOMEONE'S LIFE
When working with clients, one of the many questions I ask is: Do you want to give a gift or change someone's life? Many people automatically think of giving a gift and stop there. If you have the financial means to change someone's life, would that be something you want to do?
Here's an example of a client who initially gave a gift but then pivoted to changing someone's life:
A client's ailing husband had an excellent caregiver for many years. From what I learned, the patient was not an easy man to be with, and my client was immensely grateful for the caregiver's patience, acceptance, expertise, and continued care. When her husband died, my client could not say "thank you" enough to the caretaker. She left a nice sum of money for the caretaker in the will. My client also realized that she, too, would need a caretaker. The caretaker stayed on to take care of her.
As my client and I reviewed her values and priorities related to her legacy and her estate plan, the caretaker's name came up in our conversation. My client wanted to give a gift to the caretaker. We discussed that when my client died, the caretaker would be that much older, and working full-time would be a hardship for her. As we looked at my client's desired legacy, it became more apparent that my client wanted to give this woman freedom from having to work to support herself. Rather than a gift, she wanted to change her life and allow her to retire. With this decision, my client's estate lawyer proposed a solution that would accomplish her objectives.
TALKING ABOUT DEATH CHANGES HOW YOU LIVE
One of my favorite precepts is how talking about death changes how you live. Every 'living your legacy' client walks away wanting to incorporate at least some of what we discover during our time together. Our work together opens the door to learning more about what is important to you, at your core. It is not surprising, then, when it becomes crucial to use that information now.
An example of putting that phrase into action was when an asset manager hired me to consult her client on bequest concerns.
Her client, a single woman with no heirs, was eager to determine nonprofits, in five specific fields of interest, as the beneficiaries of her trust. The project's research phase was extensive, and as I reported back to the client, I could see her interest grow. In the end, there was enough information for her to decide which nonprofits to include in her estate plan.
We created a framework document for her trustees to use for vetting the particular organizations at the time of her death. Included in the paperwork was an explanation of her intentions, values, and beliefs. If the named organizations failed her tests, her trustees would have her guidance to fulfill her wishes with other nonprofits. I also developed a list of questions for her trustees based on the information gathered during the discovery process as a benchmark for them to follow.
With her passion ignited, the client and I discussed that she could start to change how she was living. I encouraged her to spend time getting to know the organizations and the people involved – staff, board, and volunteers – as they are like-minded. She started donating to these nonprofits in the present time, building relationships with the executive directors and staff, volunteering, and giving her life more purpose and joy.
~~~~~~~~~~
IN CONSIDERATION AS A SINGLE WOMAN
"About two-thirds of people living alone at home over age 85 are women," according to a 2017 study from the Society of Actuaries.
Not surprising, as all the actuarial tables show, women continue to live longer than men. Given the many statistics that show concerns of women's financial wellness, the financial dependency women have on others, and women's overall relationship with money, planning your legacy as a single woman has its share of extra steps in preparing for beneficiaries. It can get complicated as single women tend to be more concerned about their financial picture during their lifetime. I have spoken and written often of Bag Lady Syndrome, and that topic resonates strongly with women (and men, just not as often).
~~~~~~~~~~
OTHER CHANGES I NEEDED TO MAKE, AND NOW MY CLIENTS DO THIS AS WELL
Immediately following my medical form changes, I acknowledged that I needed to change my estate's trustees as my ex-husband clearly didn't belong on that form either. I know all too well the burden of being an estate executor, having assisted in the process several times. I chose two best friends and wrote a lengthy explanation of my thought process, my philosophy, including my mission statement, gifting, and values.
I asked both of my friends to read my wishes now to ensure I was as clear as I intended to be. Once the editing process was complete, I added the following, "I know that there will be many more pieces of my estate puzzle than I can anticipate at the moment. I asked you both to do this as I completely trust your judgment. At any point, if you find yourself asking, 'What would Emily do?' the answer is 'She would ask you to use your judgment.'" I did include, "Besides, I'll be dead, so you won't have to worry about my reaction!" There is nothing like a little humor to lighten the atmosphere.
HOW TO CREATE A ROAD MAP FOR YOUR LOVED ONES
In my practice, I help clients in creating a legacy road map. I use Go Wish Cards to help people find the words that help them identify what is important to them and how to talk about it. Additionally, I take them through a visioning exercise to help them identify their values, which allows them to center their legacy plans in keeping with how they live. Lastly, I encourage all of my clients to write letters to the beneficiaries, both the individuals and organizations, to add the personal reasons behind the gift. It is one thing to ONLY be told you are receiving money. It is something completely different to learn how meaningful you are, AND you are receiving a gift.
~~~~~~~~~~~
ASK YOURSELF
The following is a list of questions to help you start ideating about your life and legacy:
What are Your Biggest Fears of Being Alone?
What are your biggest fears at the end? What keeps you up at night by being alone, and how do we solve that?
Who and What Has Impacted Your Life?
How do you want to honor that or them? Use people who will appreciate the importance of what you are asking of them after you are gone.
What Would you Like to See Changed in The World?
Identify and explore your values. Is there something that you prioritize above all else, where you'd like to make an impact?
What Does My Generosity Include?
Is there a nonprofit that you'd like to support, and/or someone directly?
Why Is This Important to Me
Share why you want what you want. It doesn't take a magic formula to plan your legacy. It's a personal process. People won't know your reasons behind your choices unless you communicate them.
~~~~~~~~~~~
P.S. As I was writing this blog, a former client sent me the following text: "Thank you for helping me understand a different way to prepare for what my children will go through after my death...so that my children will feel empowered, loved, trusted, and deeply cherished.
In case you are wondering, my siblings and I were blindsided by my father's will today. It's not a huge deal to us financially, but it's what it signifies vis-à-vis all of the things I listed in the text above. The grief alone was bad enough. But to have this heaped on top today was almost unbearable. Thanks. I'll call soon."
My heart aches for my client. This is not how it has to be. Ever.
Discovering Your Money Money | Living Your Legacy | Determining Your Philanthropic Values
Emily Scott, Emily Scott AND
emily@emilyscottand.com | 415-609-1900 | emilyscottand.com
Unleash the Power of Vulnerability
"I have never heard a person speak with such vulnerability at a business conference as you just were." Really? Moi? My presentation at a national conference of financial and philanthropic professionals carried the title, "What Was and What Will Be: A Client in Transition." I presented case studies, mine included, to illustrate the best and worst practices of advisors' vis-a-vis the retention of clients. The audience learned that while some professionals recognized I was as much of their client as my then-husband, others dismissed me as "the wife of the client." The retelling of my experiences brought audible gasps from the audience. My frame of reference was, "I'm here to tell these people what it is like on the client-side of the table," and if I was going to share those stories, I need to tell the truth — you couldn't make up some of these experiences.
"I have never heard a person speak with such vulnerability at a business conference as you just were." Really? Moi? My presentation at a national conference of financial and philanthropic professionals carried the title, "What Was and What Will Be: A Client in Transition." I presented case studies, mine included, to illustrate the best and worst practices of advisors' vis-a-vis the retention of clients. The audience learned that while some professionals recognized I was as much of their client as my then-husband, others dismissed me as "the wife of the client." The retelling of my experiences brought audible gasps from the audience. My frame of reference was, "I'm here to tell these people what it is like on the client-side of the table," and if I was going to share those stories, I need to tell the truth — you couldn't make up some of these experiences.
When many people echoed the vulnerability aspect of my speech, I was dumbfounded and asked a friend precisely what that meant. She expounded, "You talked about not just what happened to you, but how it felt. You voiced what was going on, intellectually and emotionally." The view that I am unguarded is a disconnect because my perspective is that I am sharing my truth. It is my nature to include emotions in the equation, so I didn't think this was anything new or unordinary.
I want to know how people feel, and I assume everyone is like that. In jest, one of my friends introduces me, "This is my friend, Emily. Don't ask her how she is; she'll tell you," For the record, when I ask, "How are you?" I follow it with "That's a real question."
I have come to understand that not everyone comes to vulnerability easily. Many people mask their emotions — especially when talking about their feelings regarding their wealth because it is more comfortable, more conforming, and less open to judgment. (factoid: People would rather talk about sex with their children than talk about money).
"The problem is...that you cannot selectively numb those hard feelings without numbing the other effects and emotions. When we numb those, we numb joy, numb gratitude, numb happiness, and then we are miserable and are looking for purpose and meaning." -Brene Brown
The realization that my inherent superpower, of being vulnerable, led me to a personal and professional transformation. I'm here to tell you there is power in being vulnerable.
Having been both the client and the professional, I know that vulnerability is at the crux of people's challenges. Many people don't know how to address their emotional turmoil around their wealth. Clients don't readily share their emotional sensitivities regarding their wealth or estate plan with their lawyers and advisors, which causes dilemmas or issues for these professionals. Shame and fear are what keep many people from sharing their stories.
Being Vulnerable Means Being Open to Possibilities
An investment manager referred me to his clients, a couple, who were continually battling about their financial needs and wants. After asking each of them about the state of their marriage, what they trusted and liked about each other, we established that their intentions were loving. I clarified that our conversations would occur in a safe space to encourage each of them to let down their guard. The notion of someone hearing you, alone, is a great place to start. Each of them completed my worksheets to define their individual money story and share it only with me. By detailing your money story and saying it out loud, a person can feel acceptance and understanding. When we were all back together, the couple shared their stories. By sharing, they were asking one another for recognition — to listen with empathy and without judgment. We then went over the similarities and differences with both of their stories, acknowledging the source of one another's emotions around their finances, taking down the barriers that stood between them, and reframing the conversation to one of recognizing different perspectives, options, and compromise.
Vulnerability Brings Resolution
I have come to appreciate that hiding from one's truth is more painful than accepting it. A client, anxious about his legacy and feeling emotionally misaligned with his estate plan, came to me to discuss possible revisions. Chief among his concerns was his adult children's futures, and what might transpire upon his passing. He had children with two different women with dissimilar financial capabilities. He realized that the two sets of children would have different inheritances on the maternal side, and he was not sure how to reconcile this fact in his plan. In his plan, he wanted each child to feel equally loved by him and not equate his love with the monetary inheritance they would receive from him.
In a review of the information he had shared, the questions he pondered, and the gaps between what existed and his feelings, it was evident that he wasn't fully sharing his truth. Our conversations were the perfect opportunities for him to open up about his thoughts and feelings about his legacy. We role-played the dialogues that he could have with his family to gain further clarity. He reported back that each conversation was one of the most meaningful, loving, and informative conversations he has ever had with his children.
From there, we were able to document the changes for his estate lawyer to facilitate the revisions needed in his estate plan.
How to Unleash the Power of Vulnerability
Recognize that your need to protect yourself is limiting you. When we know we are about to be judged, we give the least personal information because we believe we are reducing possible ammunition for others to use. How can you discover the power of vulnerability?
1. Appreciate the journey you are about to take.
The information you will learn about yourself now will enable you to move on. The fear of the unknown is the worst of it. Owning part of the outcome is vital. Vulnerability isn't happening to you; you are part of the solution and choosing to be vulnerable.
2. Know your audience.
There is space and opportunity to offer your truth. It would help if you appreciate your audience and how much they can take in and how much you can take with their reaction. By knowing your audience, you are no longer hiding when you share. Like wearing a coat in winter and walking out into the cold, you are insulated and prepared for what you might hear.
3. Test the waters.
There is a difference between vulnerability in-the-moment versus in the past. Present and past emotions are on different levels, with the former carrying a more significant sting. Tell a story from your past. You will have fewer feelings about it because it has already happened. By sharing, you will get a sense of whether someone hears what you have to say. Ask yourself, why do you want to share this information? What do you want the outcome to be? Sharing a story can help teach you adaptability and resilience. It will help to reframe your vulnerability.
4. Bring on the power.
The fear of 'I'm not good enough' can be top of mind, opening the door for doubt and fear. You have to be prepared to get an unwanted answer. Be resilient by believing in yourself in the face of a challenge. Your wellbeing is not dependent on the response. Learn to be more adaptable by embracing vulnerability, having courage, and "a willingness to do something when there are no guarantees." If people can adapt, they can resource their strengths and find power in vulnerability.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I explain my professional foundation with the following: Vulnerability is a strength. I believe that people want to matter, be seen, and be heard. Our conversations are confidential and free of judgment. I also come to the conversation curious, which allows me to listen differently and more deeply. This core philosophy encourages trust, which opens the door to a far more emotional conversation about money — where the magic of vulnerability transpires and eventually leads to clarity and peace of mind.
Identifying Your Emotions Around Your Money Can Bring You Peace
For many people, when the pandemic and shelter in place dramatically changed our personal and professional lives, their general anxieties about financial security shot to the sky. As someone who has "bag lady syndrome," I was surprised that I didn't crawl under my bed and assume a fetal position. The hypothetical scenario of the world coming to an end was something I imagined for years. But I didn't hide, and I will circle back to why in a few paragraphs.
The reality is that no one can predict when the economy will rebound, and very few, if any, are suggesting anytime soon. For now, people will, understandably so, continue to be worried about their financial future.
For many people, when the pandemic and shelter in place dramatically changed our personal and professional lives, their general anxieties about financial security shot to the sky. As someone who has "bag lady syndrome," I was surprised that I didn't crawl under my bed and assume a fetal position. The hypothetical scenario of the world coming to an end was something I imagined for years. But I didn't hide, and I will circle back to why in a few paragraphs.
The reality is that no one can predict when the economy will rebound, and very few, if any, are suggesting anytime soon. For now, people will, understandably so, continue to be worried about their financial future.
The subject of money and anxiety is so topical that the New York Times writer, Paul Sullivan, recently wrote about people turning to financial therapists for help. He states, "financial therapists have advanced degrees in psychology or clinical social work." He neglected to mention the few of us who, with a financial services background, empathic listening skills, and practical experience, have already unearthed the value of blending the technical and the human side of money — that doing so is an act of financial therapy in itself.
The human side of money is a relevant topic every single day.
My work with clients to identify their emotional relationship as it relates to their money and their future has confirmed my perspective that wealth is profoundly personal and carries a complex set of feelings and thoughts. By working together to uncover the client's money stories, I can guide my clients, define objectives, navigate challenges, set goals, and help them to feel better about their financial future. For those clients in personal relationships, through learning about their own and each other's money narratives, communications are enhanced as the recognition of differences and similarities come to light. This is especially true now, as we live in such a heightened state of vulnerability, unknown, and concern.
The participants in "Your Money Story" workshops and seminars that I conduct review their backgrounds with the lens focused on implicit and explicit messages from childhood to adulthood. Moving from past to present, the revelations of how those earlier messages manifest into beliefs, thoughts, and actions surface. With that new-found information, each cohort member can reframe their money attitudes and perceptions to create a plan that resonates with who they are.
As promised, the big reveal as to why I am still standing versus curled up under a rock is because I know my money story. I can tell you firsthand that it's a liberating process to have gone through. I am aware of why I have bag lady syndrome because of the messages I received as a child of a refugee father, a depression-era mother, and of their failed marriage, which dramatically changed my mother's financial situation. I appreciate that the need to understand and protect my financial resources caused me to be very risk-aware — aware being the operative word — which, in turn, caused me to ask many questions for every investment my ex-husband wanted to make. I do admit I am curious about almost everything and frequently want more information.
Knowing my money story lowered the influence my bag lady syndrome has in my life; she is now only a member of my internal committee, not the chairperson. My recognition of my triggers and fears moved me to calmly call my financial advisor and ask for a cash reserve with a longer time horizon. This move enabled me to continue to focus on what is important to me; acts of service, working with clients, being a loving partner, friend, and caretaker. This mind shift was such a dramatic departure from what she and I expected from me, that I joked with her that my measured response might have been too shocking for her. Read my money story here.
"The universe is made of stories, not of atoms." – Muriel Rukeyser
Our money story is an emotional expression. We all have a money story that influences our beliefs and the choices we make. What we can't recognize, we can't change. Now is an ideal time to put your money story into perspective, to identify what is important to you as it relates to your assets, and to put your money story to work for you. It is essential that you know it to have the connectivity between your vision, values, and money.